Good to Great: How to Make the Leap (Book Digest)

Good to Great argues that many of the conventional paths to building an outstanding company are dead ends. Jim Collins and his team identified companies that made the leap from average performance to exceptional results sustained over fifteen years and looked for what set them apart from similar companies that didn’t achieve greatness.

They found that building a great company isn’t about bold strategies, charismatic CEOs, motivational visions, or technological transformation.

Instead, it's about disciplined people, disciplined thought, and disciplined action—all building momentum like a flywheel until breakthrough occurs. Companies become great when they combine humble but determined leaders with a stellar team, build a culture that is hopeful about the future yet determined to face the truth about the present, and focus relentlessly on their theory of what they can do better than anyone else.

Level 5 Leadership: Humility Plus Will

Great companies don’t have celebrity CEOs. They have what Collins calls Level 5 leaders: individuals who blend extreme personal humility with intense professional will.

Darwin Smith of Kimberly-Clark is a great example. He was shy and not particularly charismatic, yet he made the most dramatic decision in the company's history: selling the paper mills that had been the foundation of Kimberly-Clark for a hundred years to compete in consumer products against Procter & Gamble.

The decision required stoic resolve, but Smith never sought personal glory. In retirement, he simply said, "I never stopped trying to become qualified for the job."

Level 5 leaders channel their ambition into the company, not themselves. They attribute success to good luck and other people, while taking personal responsibility for poor results. This stands in stark contrast to celebrity CEOs who credit themselves for wins and blame circumstances for losses.

The research found that celebrity leaders who rode in from the outside were actually negatively correlated with taking a company from good to great.

First Who, Then What: Getting the Right People on the Bus

Good-to-great leaders start with people rather than strategy. The idea is simple but counterintuitive: First get the right people on the bus, the wrong people off the bus, and the right people in the right seats. Then figure out where to drive it.

This approach offers three key advantages. First, having the right people means you can adapt as circumstances change, which is critical in an uncertain world. Second, the right people don't need to be tightly managed or motivated: They're self-motivated by the inner drive to produce great results. Third, great people attract more great people.

Wells Fargo in the 1980s is a good example. CEO Carl Reichardt built an executive team so strong that nearly every member went on to become CEO of a major company. Rather than fearing their departure, Wells Fargo accepted that building the best management team in the industry meant some members would be recruited away.

Here are three practical techniques to build the right team:

1. When in doubt, don't hire; keep looking. Circuit City's Alan Wurtzel put it this way: "You don't compromise [on quality]. We find another way to get through until we find the right people."

2. When you know you need to make a people change, act. Letting the wrong people hang around is unfair to everyone—it drives away the best people and wastes the time of those who need to move on.

3. Put your best people on your biggest opportunities, not your biggest problems. When Kimberly-Clark sold the mills, Darwin Smith moved all the best paper executives to the consumer business, despite their lack of consumer experience.

Crucially, compensation isn’t the key to getting superior performance from your team. So long as compensation is reasonable, it falls away as a distinguishing variable. Compensation gets the right people on the bus, it can’t manipulate the wrong people into the right behaviors.

Confront the Brutal Facts (Yet Never Lose Faith)

Great decisions come from confronting brutal facts while maintaining unwavering faith that you will prevail. This duality is captured in what Collins calls the Stockdale Paradox, named after Admiral James Stockdale, who survived eight years as a prisoner of war in Vietnam.

When asked who didn't make it out of the prison camps, Stockdale replied: "The optimists. They were the ones who said, 'We're going to be out by Christmas.' And Christmas would come, and Christmas would go...They died of a broken heart."

Stockdale maintained absolute faith that he would prevail while confronting the brutal reality of his situation.

Comparing Kroger to A&P illustrates the importance of getting this right. Both faced the same brutal fact: their traditional grocery store model was becoming obsolete. Kroger confronted this reality and made the painful decision to convert or close every single old store, exiting entire regions. A&P, meanwhile, closed the research unit that revealed these uncomfortable truths and clung to its dying model.

The result: Kroger generated returns eighty times better than A&P.

Good-to-great leaders create a climate where truth is heard by:

1. Leading with questions, not answers

2. Engaging in dialogue and debate, not coercion

3. Conducting autopsies without blame

4. Building "red flag" mechanisms that turn information into facts that leadership can’t ignore

The Hedgehog Concept: Simplicity Within Three Circles

Isaiah Berlin wrote a classic essay in which he distinguished two ways of knowing the world: a fox who knows many things and a hedgehog who knows one big thing.

Collins found that great companies are hedgehogs. They develop a simple, focused concept that guides everything they do.

A Hedgehog Concept sits at the intersection of three circles:

1. What can you be the best in the world at? This isn't a goal, it's an understanding (and reflects a candid assessment of what you cannot be the best at). Wells Fargo realized it couldn't beat Citicorp at global banking, but it could be the best at running a bank like a business in the western United States.

2. What drives your economic engine? Every good-to-great company discovered a single "economic denominator" (taking the form of profit per X) that had the greatest impact. Walgreens chose profit per customer visit, not profit per store. This led to their phenomenally successful clustering strategy in which they put stores on every corner.

3. What are you deeply passionate about? You can't manufacture passion. The Philip Morris executives had genuine passion for their independent cowboy identity, while competitors diversified into areas that generated no passion.

Walgreens is a perfect example. Their Hedgehog Concept was simply: the best, most convenient drugstores with high profit per customer visit.

Their actions flowed from this Hedgehog Concept: They replaced inconvenient locations with corner lots, clustered stores tightly in urban areas, and added high-margin services like one-hour photo development. This simple concept generated cumulative stock returns 15 times the market average.

Hedgehog Concepts don’t emerge instantly: It took an average of four years for companies to clarify their Hedgehog Concept through iterative dialogue and debate.

A Culture of Discipline

Great companies built cultures around the idea of freedom within a framework of responsibility. When you have disciplined people, you don't need hierarchy or excessive controls.

Abbott Laboratories exemplified this by creating "Responsibility Accounting," where every manager was held rigorously accountable for their return on investment, while simultaneously receiving freedom to determine the best path to their objectives.

This culture must be built, not enforced by a tyrannical disciplinarian. Companies that didn’t achieve greatness often had leaders who enforced discipline and created amazing short-term results, like Lee Iacocca at Chrysler or Al Dunlap at Scott Paper. But when these leaders left, discipline evaporated and results plummeted.

The core element of discipline is fanatical adherence to the Hedgehog Concept. Good-to-great companies followed a simple mantra: "Anything that does not fit with our Hedgehog Concept, we will not do." They became masters of what not to do, creating "stop doing" lists to systematically unplug extraneous activities.

Nucor Steel demonstrates cultural discipline brilliantly. Rather than having executive dining rooms and reserved parking, all employees' names appeared in the annual report and everyone (except safety supervisors) wore the same color hard hats. This egalitarian culture attracted disciplined people who thrived under rigorous standards.

Technology Accelerators

Technology is never the primary cause of greatness or decline. Instead, great companies use technology to accelerate their existing momentum, not to create it.

When Drugstore.com threatened Walgreens, analysts downgraded Walgreens' stock and nearly $15 billion in market value evaporated. Rather than reacting in panic, Walgreens executives paused to think. They asked: "How will the Internet connect to our convenience concept?"

They moved deliberately by following the crawl, walk, run concept. They experimented with a website, engaged in intense internal dialogue, then bet big with a sophisticated site tied directly to their stores. The result: Walgreens.com became profitable while pure dot-coms collapsed.

When evaluating new technology, consider these points:

1. Does the technology fit directly with your Hedgehog Concept?

2. If yes, become a pioneer in its application.

3. If no, do you need it at all?

4. If yes, parity is sufficient. You don’t need to be first or the best.

Eighty percent of good-to-great executives didn't even mention technology as a top five factor in their transformations. Technology can accelerate a transformation, but it cannot cause one.

The Flywheel and the Doom Loop

Collins uses the metaphor of a flywheel to describe how companies become great. You push with great effort to move the flywheel and it moves an inch. As you keep pushing, the flywheel slowly accelerates. Eventually, momentum builds and you reach a breakthrough point where it spins under its own momentum.

Good-to-great transformations happen this way: not through dramatic revolution, but through consistent buildup that leads to breakthrough. There is no single defining action, no grand program, no miracle moment.

Other companies follow a doom loop pattern: They launch new programs with great fanfare and abandon them when quick results don't materialize.

Flywheels create motivation; hyped up strategy launches don’t. When people see and feel the momentum building, they want to be part of a winning team.

Conclusion

"Good to Great" presents a fundamentally different vision of building exceptional organizations. Greatness doesn't require being in a great industry, having a celebrity CEO, or launching dramatic change programs. Instead, it requires disciplined people who engage in disciplined thought and take disciplined action.

The framework is deceptively simple: Get Level 5 leaders who blend humility with will. Get the right people on the bus before figuring out where to drive it. Confront brutal facts while maintaining unwavering faith. Develop a simple Hedgehog Concept at the intersection of what you can be best at, what drives your economics, and what you're passionate about. Build a culture of discipline where people have freedom within a framework. Use technology as an accelerator, not a creator. Push the flywheel in a consistent direction until momentum builds and breakthrough occurs.

Perhaps most importantly, the research suggests that building something great doesn't require more suffering than perpetuating mediocrity—in fact, it may require less. The key is not working harder, but focusing relentlessly on the right things and not wasting energy on everything else.

- - -

If you liked this article, check out our other book digests in our series Required Reading for Salespeople. You can also check out the P.S.I. Selling Content Page for more insights on sales communication, strategy, and leadership.

Want to build a sales process that proves value and a team that can execute? Get in touch.

For more about the author, check out Mike's bio.